Internet / ARTICLE

Peer Production from Linux to Wikipedia

Linux and Wikipedia represent peer production, a model named by Yochai Benkler, whose outputs become part of the public commons and cannot be directly priced in open markets.

Linux and Wikipedia are often treated together as a distinct kind of production. Yochai Benkler, a legal scholar, named this mode peer production. In this mode, contributions do not rely on corporate employment or market sales.

The firm-based coordination model

Classical economics holds that the most effective way to achieve cooperation and efficient distribution of results is through private for-profit enterprises selling goods or services in open markets. These firms hire employees and pay them. Employees enter contracts that oblige them to carry out tasks assigned by managers. The products created through employee labor belong to the company. The company sets prices, manages sales transactions, pays employee wages, and distributes profits generated during operations.

This arrangement addresses several coordination problems. Wages and profits align the interests of different parties. Employment contracts and managerial assignment organize work tasks. Market pricing and sales transactions route finished goods or services to buyers who are willing and able to pay. In the classical account, these mechanisms form an efficient system for cooperative production.

Peer production without binding mechanisms

Peer production provides an alternative to the behavioral model that classical economics relies on. Contractual obligations, economic incentives, and bureaucratic authority do not guarantee that participants will contribute labor, nor do they ensure that contributed labor will be effectively organized. Linux and Wikipedia produce resources that become part of the Public Commons. These commons are protected by non-exclusive intellectual property. Because of that status, the resources created through peer production cannot be given a direct price in open markets.

The absence of enforceable contracts, pay-based incentives, or managerial authority changes the coordination problem. Participation cannot be commanded. Task organization cannot be imposed through a corporate hierarchy. Outputs do not enter a conventional pricing system.

Collective autonomy and real-world limits

In its ideal form, a peer production project maintains complete collective autonomy over three areas: the scope of its work, the legitimacy of leader authority, and the selection of tasks worth investing effort in. This means the project itself decides these matters collectively, without direction from an outside owner or market. In practice, peer production appears in varying degrees. The institutions that implement it also include some that do not fully meet all of the defining criteria.

END
Feedback