AI / ARTICLE

Goldman Sachs Restricts Claude Code and GitHub to Engineers

Goldman Sachs has restricted Claude Code and GitHub to engineers, cutting off traders and bankers who used the tools to monitor client flows and build market models.

Goldman Sachs has restricted Anthropic’s Claude Code and Microsoft’s GitHub to its engineers, according to internal guidance updated in October. Most traders and bankers at the bank can no longer use the AI coding tools at work, Bloomberg News reported, following a review of productivity and risk concerns. Strats who work across trading, quantitative research, and software engineering still have access.

The change has frustrated some traders. They had used the tools to monitor client trading flows, model market moves and positions, and put together written and graphic material. Goldman spokesperson Nick Carcaterra said the bank makes certain AI tools available to staff “to determine the best use cases” across the firm.

A shift from July’s “vibe coding”

In July, chief information officer Marco Argenti was publicly promoting “vibe coding” by non-technical employees. He told Bloomberg that traders and bankers had built tools with AI and passed them to the firm’s roughly 12,000 engineers for improvement. The October guidance limits the coding agents to that group. At a conference in Turin, Argenti described Goldman’s AI adoption in waves and said developers made up the first wave.

Hong Kong restriction and Anthropic’s IPO

In April, Goldman removed Claude from its internal AI platform for bankers in Hong Kong. The bank had read its contract with Anthropic strictly, according to the Financial Times, and an Anthropic spokesperson said Claude had never been officially supported in Hong Kong. ChatGPT and Gemini remained available there. JPMorgan removed Claude from its Hong Kong approved list in June. The Hong Kong restriction was based on location and contract terms; the new restriction is based on role. Goldman’s in-house AI assistant, which uses models from several companies, is still available across the firm. The restriction applies to third-party agents that can write and run code by themselves.

Goldman remains closely tied to Anthropic. Anthropic engineers spent six months at the bank helping build Claude-based agents for trade accounting and client onboarding. Goldman and Morgan Stanley are the lead underwriters on Anthropic’s IPO, according to the S-1 filed October 26. Anthropic is expected to list on Nasdaq under the ticker ANT before the end of November. Over the next few weeks, Goldman bankers will be marketing shares in a company whose coding agent most of them are no longer allowed to use.

Why coding agents are riskier on a trading desk

Claude Code reads files, writes programs, and runs them, typically with the same access as the person using it. Code an engineer writes with it usually goes through review, testing, and deployment controls before it reaches anything important. A script a trader builds to watch client flows can end up in daily use without going through any of those. Banks are also required to keep information barriers between groups, for example between bankers working on deals and traders who could profit from knowing about them. Goldman built its internal AI platform around controls like these. A tool a trader puts together with an agent wasn’t designed with them in mind, and engineers can only check it if someone sends it their way.

Whether anyone understands the code is another issue. A Meta engineer said he now ships code he can’t fully account for, and writing software is his job. A trader using an agent to model positions is less likely to know how that code handles unusual cases, which on a trading desk can mean losses. Cost may have played a part. Agent usage is billed by the token, and several companies that gave agents to everyone have seen spending climb. Amazon shut down an internal leaderboard after employees ran agents on pointless tasks to move up it, and Accenture now funds $29 a month of Claude per employee. Bloomberg’s sources said productivity was part of Goldman’s review.

Barclays is moving in the other direction. The bank said in October that it expects half its developers to be using Claude Code by the end of the year, and three weeks later named developers among 5,000 job cuts. Like Goldman, it is giving coding agents to engineers. Unlike Goldman, it is also using them to reduce how many engineers it employs. JPMorgan and Schwab are blocking outside agents from customer accounts, and Goldman has now set limits on which of its own employees can use them.

END
Feedback